The vengeful spirit of a woman (known as The Tooth Fairy) wrongly executed in the town of Darkness Falls in the 19th Century has returned. A young man, Kyle (Chaney Kley), who claims to have seen The Tooth Fairy, is considered insane by everyone in town with the exception of his childhood girlfriend, Caitlin (Emma Caufield), and her younger brother, Michael (Lee Cormie). Kyle must now confront his fears and his past to save Michael from the hands of a small town's legendary evil...