Skip over navigation

Being Julia

Rated - 3.5 stars

Being Julia: Annette Bening

Produced by a Canadian immigrant (Robert Lantos), directed by a Hungarian (Istvan Szabo), but written by a Brit (Ronald Harwood), based on a novel by Somerset Maugham and set in and around London in the 1930s, Being Julia is a quintessential star vehicle. That star is, of course, American: Annette Bening.

Ms Bening is Julia Lambert, the toast of Shaftesbury Avenue, after yet another triumph on the London stage. A diva in the best possible sense, Julia is at the top of her game… and ruefully aware that it can only be downhill from here. Her marriage to producer Jeremy Irons is an amicable sham. She has nothing left to prove professionally, and maybe not so much more to give either. Then she's swept off her feet by an ardent young American suitor, Tom Fennel (Shaun Evans), and suddenly she feels like a new woman. Until, that is, he dumps her for a pushy young starlet glorying in the name of Avice (Lucy Punch). It's a fool move on his part.

Being Julia: Bening and Gambon

Ronald Harwood wrote The Dresser of course, and everyone involved knows the theatrical world backwards – it probably hasn't changed that much since the 1930s either. Unfortunately the familiarity extends to the audience, because there's nothing here that we haven't seen before. Being Julia is a Sunday afternoon wallow of a picture – its company, which can be brittle and amusing, but also a bit wearing if you're not in the mood. While an embarrassing surfeit of good British thesps go through their paces in roles barely worthy of them (Irons, Juliet Stevenson, Miriam Margolyes and Michael Gambon for instance) you wonder if Shaun Evans had to be quite so colourless in the role of the American bounder – wouldn't the film have had a bit more passion if we actually cared about the romance?

Sluggishly structured, such plot as there is is all an elaborate set-up for the last act, when Madame Julia gets her revenge. Even this splendidly malicious coup de théâtre has been done before, and with more style too (I will refer you once more to the sublime French classic, Les Enfants du Paradis), but Bening milks it for all its worth – including that Golden Globe which now sits on her mantlepiece – and quite right too. Without a divine diva at its centre, this would be a sorry sight indeed.

Tom Charity
tom.charity@lovefilm.com

View Details

More information about Being Julia »

Critics' Reviews

Rating of 3 stars out of 5 Radio Times

The glamour and superficiality surrounding the London theatre scene of the 1930s is brought to life in István Szabó's stylish comedy drama. Based on a W Somerset Maugham novella, it's an atmospheric tale of impetuous love and calculating revenge. An effervescent Annette Bening is the 40-something stage actress and society queen, who begins a turbulent affair with a gold-digging young American (Shaun Evans). Initially energised by their illicit meetings, the married diva is increasingly pained by Evans's playboy ways, particularly his relationship with a beautiful acting hopeful (Lucy Punch). This character-driven piece benefits from solid performances and a sharply amusing script. Although Bening occasionally overplays her role, she's no less appealing for it, while Michael Gambon is fabulous as her ghostly mentor. The film may be too affected for modern tastes, but it does delightfully convey the charms and idiosyncrasies of inter-war luvviedom.

Time Out

As her stage diva character Julia would have it, this comedy drama revolves around Annette Benings stunning... read more on www.timeout.com

Rating of 2 
	  stars out of 4 Halliwell's Film Guide

Enjoyable bitchy period comedy set among people who regard real life as a rehearsal for the theatre.

See all 3 Critics' Reviews »

Members' Reviews

Reviews Voted Most Helpful

Rated - 5 starsYou won't get bored

A customer from uk , 07/03/2005

You don't have to be a fan of Annette Bening (or Jeremy Irons) to enjoy this high-spirited tale of theatrical life - or rather, Julia Lambert's life, to be specific.

Based on a novella by my one of my all-time favorite authors, W. Somerset Maugham, Being Julia is sort of like All About Eve, except not as stage-y. It's a period piece, taking place in England in the '30s, where burnt-out Diva Extraordinaire Julia Lambert is moaning and groaning about her tedious, boring life to anyone who will listen, including her weathered and weary husband (Irons, drolly pipe-puffing his way through the film as only he could). She meets a young, handsome, American fan/opportunist (Shaun Evans, highly effective) and together they rekindle Julia's lust for life.

This is just the first half hour - it gets better and more and more outrageous (and of course more FUN) as it goes on. Needless to say, you won't be bored; in fact, I left the theater smiling and shaking my head.

  59 out of 62 people found this review helpful

Read all reviews

Rated - 3 starsOK, but the book's better

Rehan from London [Highly rated reviewer] , 21/06/2005

Sometimes when a book is good (as Somerset Maugham?s Theatre is) it?s as well to wonder why a narrative that depends on a great deal of internalised feeling could be expected to make a good film: so much subtlety is lost in broadening the characterisations (like changing the character of Tom from an aspirational suburban Londoner into an American) and motivations that it scarcely seems worthwhile. Read the book.

That said, this isn?t a hopeless effort, in fact it?s a moderately enjoyable film. Annette Bening is surprisingly good at the arch stageyness of her character, and Jeremy Irons (a predictable and unappealing actor) is well-cast. The standard of production values is high, and the simplified if vulgarised story is clear enough.

But it?s also a bit fluffy, and the direction is unexpectedly pedestrian: there are, for example, far too many ?reaction? shots, and a good deal too much unmotivated laughter to clumsily show how much people are supposed to be enjoying themselves. The climactic scene where Julia upstages her rival is hopeless anachronistic and unconvincing, and elsewhere too the period detail is inaccurate, for example in the grooming and teeth of Juliet Stevenson?s character.

There are worse ways to spend an hour and a half, but a lot of better ones too.

  16 out of 16 people found this review helpful

Read all reviews

Rated - 4 starsGreat fun!

Nobbylamp Nobbylamp from Bromley, England , 01/06/2005

Reminded me of a Noel Coward stage play. Excellent performance from Annette Bening. Great dialogue which keeps you smiling your way through it. Bening moves between Katherine Hepburn and Bette Davis, which only enhances her fabulous portrayal of the likeable and sometimes perfectly 'over the top' character. Also a special mention for Michael Gambon who is superb.

Was extremely pleased with the movie and much, much better and a lot funnier than I anticipated . Can recommend it.

  10 out of 11 people found this review helpful

Read all reviews

Rated - 4 starsFun

philip reardon from St Albans , 13/06/2005

Could think of worse ways of spending 100 mins. It won,t change your life its jus FUN!

  5 out of 5 people found this review helpful

Read all reviews

Most Recent Reviews

Rated - 5 starsYou won't get bored

A customer from uk , 07/03/2005

You don't have to be a fan of Annette Bening (or Jeremy Irons) to enjoy this high-spirited tale of theatrical life - or rather, Julia Lambert's life, to be specific.

Based on a novella by my one of my all-time favorite authors, W. Somerset Maugham, Being Julia is sort of like All About Eve, except not as stage-y. It's a period piece, taking place in England in the '30s, where burnt-out Diva Extraordinaire Julia Lambert is moaning and groaning about her tedious, boring life to anyone who will listen, including her weathered and weary husband (Irons, drolly pipe-puffing his way through the film as only he could). She meets a young, handsome, American fan/opportunist (Shaun Evans, highly effective) and together they rekindle Julia's lust for life.

This is just the first half hour - it gets better and more and more outrageous (and of course more FUN) as it goes on. Needless to say, you won't be bored; in fact, I left the theater smiling and shaking my head.

  59 out of 62 people found this review helpful

Read all highest rated reviews

Rated - 3 starsPleasant English Chocolate-Box Period Drama

A classical actor from deep in the luscious green valleys of stunning Mid-Wales. , 03/10/2005

It's a pleasant film, surviving only by way of its glitter. Indeed it's about egocentric actors/actresses and in this case egocentrism largely wins the day. It's foppery but it's fun, but it's totally inconsequential. Good budget, fine preparation, good acting, well-edited. This is just the film to show at the old-age pensioners' Christmas Party. They'll love it.

  2 out of 2 people found this review helpful

Read all highest rated reviews