Skip over navigation

The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe

Rated - 3.5 stars

Bereft of Lord of the Rings this Christmas, Disney have come up with the next best thing and have gone all guns ablazin' with an adaptation of C.S Lewis' classic children's tale, The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe.

The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe

The similarities between Lewis' work and Tolkien's is abundant, hardly surprising considering they met as young professors at Oxford back in the 20s. Director Andrew Adamson (his first 'real-life' feature after directing Shrek and Shrek 2) aims to keep this link very much alive; shooting many of the action scenes for Narnia in New Zealand (a la Peter Jackson) and employing Weta - the company that created the special effects for Lord of the Rings - to weave their magic once more.

The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the WardrobeAnd weave their magic they do. It's a risky business finding four children to carry the weight of such a large film, but Adamson's three year casting process has paid off dividends. The children play their parts with aplomb, with a particularly superb performance from young Georgie Henley as Lucy Pevensie - the finder of the portal from wardrobe to Narnia..

Adamson has got the balance between action and acting down to a tee, while the battle scenes are impressive (those expecting action of Lord of the Rings stature may be disappointed) it is the relationship between the characters that resonates most succinctly. Lucy's first encounter with Mr. Tumnas (played by the wonderful James McAvoy) is truly magical.

The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the WardrobeMuch has been spoken about Tilda Swinton's role as the 'epitome of evil' the White Witch Jadis and for good reason. Swinton is iconic as Jadis. Her costumes are fantastic, increasing her statue to monstrous proportions and making poor Edward (Skandar Keynes) her unfortunate ward look Imp-like in comparison. The decision to play her with quiet contempt makes her all the more threatening - and even though she doesn't look half as frightening as many of her ugly accomplices - her nightmare inducing performance is on a par with the Child catcher of Chitty Chitty Bang Bang fame.

Worryingly Adamson admitted that a few years back a studio (which shall remain nameless) had intended to turn the whole book into a contemporary American rendition - C.S Lewis' would be turning in his grave at the thought. Much has also been made about the American Christian Right hijacking the film, but Adamson is insistent: "Obviously C.S Lewis was a Christian apologist - but to me, spirituality and religion is a very personal issue, and its up to the audience and reader to interpret it as they wish. I've made a movie of the book - and what you get from the book you'll see in the movie."

Narnia is in safe hands with Adamson at the helm, he has created a faithful and magical adaptation that will delight generations to come.

Helen Cowley

View Details

More information about The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe »

Critics' Reviews

New York Times

The spirit of the book is very much intact....[The film uses] available technology to capture both the mythic power of Lewis's tale and, even better, its charm.

USA Today

Its epic scope and elaborate battles will raise comparisons with Peter Jackson's adaptation of J.R.R. Tolkien's trilogy...

Time Out

The twin shadows of the Harry Potter and Lord of the Rings franchises hang unmistakeably over Disneys... read more on www.timeout.com

See all 4 Critics' Reviews »

Members' Reviews

Reviews Voted Most Helpful

Rated - 5 starsA Classic For All Ages

Lighthouse from BRIGHTON [Highly rated reviewer] , 14/09/2006

Stop pretending this is a children’s film. If you are eight or a hundred and eight this movie is a classic.

C S Lewis conjured up a magic land and Narnia still holds a kind of mystery for us all.

This film manages to satisfy even the most jaded amongst us. The kids in this production are spot on as is the directing. So do not compare this to films that have all the action and no heart. This is right up there with the best. A film with a soul that is a fine addition to the books. Wonderful stuff.

  47 out of 50 people found this review helpful

Read all reviews

Rated - 5 starsA special film

A customer from Cheshire, England , 12/12/2005

Any one who loves this book should not be disappointed with this film adaptation. Disney have made their best film in a long time. Films never ever come near to truly capturing the full essence of a much-loved classic, but this one does manage to do get as close as a film is likely to get. Disney were taking a huge risk here as most of their audience will be adults who loved this story as a child and still carry that love into adult-hood, and would not be willing to give acclaim if not truly justified.

Aslan is superb, you'll be convinced that he is real. His death is well portrayed although nowhere near as cruel as in the book, probably to save the youngsters in the audience from bawling their eyes out, although it didnt save all the adults from shedding a tear (myself and a friend included). Opening scenes are very dark and dingy (air raids and black-out curtains), but once into Narnia the scenes are beautiful. Should not be compared to LOTR or HP&TGOF, this film is different in a sense that you can truly believe in it. The White Witch was well portrayed, she was suitably evil and cold in the battle scene, but the true winner in this film was Mr Tumnus, he couldn't possibly have been depicted in a better way. The scenes between him and Lucy are special - probably the best acted in the film. Lucy is great, and Edmund was ok, but Peter and Susan were terribly wooden and didnt manage to carry the characters well. Watch out for Philip - his couple of one-liners will give you a laugh. 9.9/10.

  28 out of 30 people found this review helpful

Read all reviews

Rated - 3 starsBrilliant

betsie1 from West Lothian , 10/12/2005

Brilliant film for the kids and adults a like. The talking animals was a hit

With the kids. Couple of jumpy bits in it. The badgers were good. And the

White Witch is brill.

  15 out of 16 people found this review helpful

Read all reviews

Rated - 4 starsTrue to the original

Shimo from Belfast , 25/12/2005

I haven't read the book or watched the original movie since I was very young, however this movie brought back the memories in force. I remember how I felt when I saw it as a child, and the story started coming back to be.

The story is kept intact, the special effects are very good and it is enjoyable. A bad feature of it, however, is the very annoying children acting in it. Thankfully they aren't annoying enough to ruin it.

  15 out of 19 people found this review helpful

Read all reviews

Most Recent Reviews

Rated - 5 starsQuick Review

Tops from Luton , 02/12/2007

I am a family guy and really enjoyed this as this was one of my best books when I was small. Few parts are not suitable for small children. I have a 4years8months old daughter and I would not let her see this. Overall very good and enjoyable. Watch it before you let small children see this. Very magical with excellent characters.

  1 out of 1 person found this review helpful

Read all highest rated reviews

Rated - 3 starsChildhood Favourite - but too safe

A customer from Garden of England , 05/04/2006

Went to see the film with mixed feelings as the books were and still are a firm favourite. The film ultimately doesn't hit the spot. I like the first scenes with the war and bombing - sets the story up nicely but then the drama just dribbles away. It feels like the BBC adaptation (which was good) but with a few effects added and you never really felt anyone was in danger even in battle,it was all a bit pedestrian. Aslan looked the part but didn't feel the part - not terrible enough after all he wasn't 'a tame lion' and his death scene felt like something out of the Muppets. A bit like the dead unicorn scene in Harry Potter is was all just too safe. I agree with the reviewer who was disappointed in the depiction of the snowy Narnia - looked like Surrey after a snow fall. Come on chaps - bit more imagination. I agree that Mr Tumnus was the best thing in the film. LOTR caught the essence of the books - This didn't. However if you don't know the stories I'm sure you will enjoy the film as it stands. I cried watching ET - nothing in this film (apart from the quality of it) made me cry!!

  2 out of 2 people found this review helpful

Read all highest rated reviews