Skip over navigation

The Painted Veil

Rated - 3.5 stars

The PainteD Veil

Picture poor Kitty Fane (Naomi Watts), in a white summer dress, kicking her heels in a Chinese paddy field, wondering what on earth she is doing here.

The answer is banal enough: she married in haste. Not out of love, but peevishness. She knows her very respectable family has already written her off as a lost cause, so she accepts Walter's proposal to prove them wrong. Within weeks she is in Shanghai with her straight-laced husband, looking out at the rain, bored, lonely, and depressed.

From there - and the film wisely makes short work of this - it's but a skip to an adulterous affair with the dapper Charlie Townsend (Liev Schreiber). He's everything Walter is not: witty, self-confident, romantic, and a complete and utter cad. It's a pathetic affair and it ends abruptly when Walter finds out.

And this is where things get interesting:

To Kitty's dismay, neither man is remotely inclined to do what she imagines to be the decent thing (allow her to divorce Walter and remarry Charlie).

On the contrary, Walter (Edward Norton) will divorce her immediately and leave her reputation in ruins unless she sets out with him into the country that very night. There is cholera epidemic inland. He isn't a doctor, but they need help and he can give it. He expects his wife to be right there at his side.

It might not seem like it, but this impulsively noble, altruistic gesture is tantamount to plotting his suicide and her murder, or so Kitty comes to believe.

Somerset Maugham's 1925 novel has been filmed twice before, once with Greta Garbo in 1934, and then with Eleanor Parker under the title The Seventh Sin (1957).

The PainteD Veil

It's hardly run of the mill fare to come out of Hollywood these days, and there was surprise in some quarters that Warner Bros didn't make more of an Oscar push for it last year (a commercial decision, no doubt).

Scripted by Ron Nyswaner (Philadelphia) and directed by John Curran, whose last film, We Don't Live Here Anymore, was also an unusually penetrating portrait of marital collapse (also with Ms. Watts), The Painted Veil lives up to its pedigree.

Naomi Watts is particularly impressive as she reveals a self-centered, frivolous young woman who gradually comes to the painful realization of how superficial she really is. At more or less the same time, she begins to understand and even admire her husband. Finally, with death all around, she falls in love with him.

The PainteD Veil

Movies are supposed to take you on a journey and this one does just that. Watts ensures that the emotional voyage is every bit as compelling as the exotic scenery.

If the film has a weakness, it's in the form of executive producer Edward Norton, who is just too muscular (in a skinny sort of way) to play Maugham's starchy Englishman. Toby Jones (Truman Capote in Infamous) is so good as the only other white man fool enough to stay in situ, you wish he'd been cast in the lead. Of course that film would never have been made.

Tom Charity
tom.charity@lovefilm.com

View Details

More information about The Painted Veil »

Members' Reviews

Reviews Voted Most Helpful

Rated - 4 starsBehind the Veil

A customer from London, England , 26/04/2007

As the starting credits roll and I see that not only are Naomi Watts and Edward Norton starring in this movie, they also produced it. My heart sinks as several previous examples of vanity projects flit through my mind. Thankfully I most pleasantly surprised. The Painted Veil is a long, cool drink of water. If you will forgive me labouring the metaphor: though indeed long and cool, like such a drink, it is also refreshing. Reminiscent of films not often made anymore, such as Out of Africa, this is a cinematically beautiful, poignant tale of love, betrayal and the consequences of both. Although I would agree there is a distantness both in performance and presentation, this is just as it ought to be and reflects the quiet intensity of our leads’ struggle and the repressive social conformity of the period aptly. It is a cast of quite unsympathetic characters and it is a tribute to Ron Nyswaner that they have not been “prettied up” by Hollywood and are allowed to retain their flaws. In fact the only real mark of the Hollywood powers-that-be is an increase in the sex and passion quota quite out of keeping with the book (yet secretly quite satisfying). The casting is excellent. Edward Norton excels as the hopelessly repressed yet passionate doctor; although making up with intensity what he lacks in dark brooding power. The sheer brilliance of the supporting cast and the beauty of China are what lift this tale out of the dryness such an internalised tale of conflict threatens. Director John Curran has definitely proven himself one to watch and it is nice to know that there is always an exception to the rule…even when it comes to vanity projects.

  105 out of 106 people found this review helpful

Read all reviews

Rated - 3 starsWorth watching

Not so Silent Bob from Edinburgh , 27/09/2007

A beautifully shot film, good acting though there seems to be something lacking in substance. You feel that this should have 'epic' written all over it but it comes up a little short. Still well worth a watch though

  54 out of 60 people found this review helpful

Read all reviews

Rated - 4 starsGripping,moving, beautiful...Words fail me in describing this masterpiece

A customer from North London , 06/05/2007

It is rare these days, to see a movie that concentrates so implicitly on character and plot development, that it cannot fail but to grab the viewers' attention completely. The pace of the film was perfect. The film addresses the story from a historical point when the British were in China and there was plenty of unrest afoot. But the film makers spared no expense in unravelling a really humane, moving story between two people. The lead characters were well cast and did justice to the characters of the wronged, Dr.Fane (Norton)and his adulterous wife, Kitty (Watts).What makes this story so beautiful and endearing is that it takes the viewer on a scenic journey of two people's life: starting with a loveless marriage, adultery, and the backlash of adultery (Dr. Fane deciding to endanger both their lives to move to a distant village with cholera to volunteer his services), and what ensues is a truly touching love story, when both slowly start opening up to each other in the backdrop of death, violence and despair. It's a superb film that I would recommend to anyone who likes watching a thoughtful, well constructed movie with superb acting, actors and a really gripping story. Don't miss!

  38 out of 38 people found this review helpful

Read all reviews

Rated - 4 starsOld fashioned but good

PJB from Leicester , 10/05/2007

Yes, ok I agree with that it is a slow burning film which might make it less attractive to an audience used to crashes and bangs but just allow yourself to be absorbed in the beauty of the cinematography and the perfectly understated acting of the two main protagonists Edward Norton & Naomi Watts. Mind you Ed Norton never does anything other than understatement (American X being a possible exception). There is a touch of the Merchant / Ivory about this film but it doesn't suffer for that. It is unashamedly old fashioned with the emotions being implied (accurate for the time period) rather than splashed all over the screen which might be more accessible to a younger audience.

Sit back and enjoy and you will come out after two hours wondering where the time went and feeling that you have spent the time well.

  25 out of 27 people found this review helpful

Read all reviews

Most Recent Reviews

Rated - 4 starsBeautiful Film

A customer from Surrey, England , 22/08/2007

I loved this film. It was beautiful. I loved the scenes of China and the colonial feel of the movie. The trailer to the film was over dramatised so the film wasn't what I was expecting- it was better than I expected in a different way- it was wonderful to watch and I was captured from the first scene to the last- I didn't want it to end!

This film resonates with real life far more than so many hollywood movies and I loved that.

A beautiful and breathtaking film.

  12 out of 13 people found this review helpful

Read all highest rated reviews

Rated - 5 starsfab movie

butterfly62 from Exeter , 29/11/2007

thoroughly enjoyed the film, outcome not what i expected, keeps you guessing a bit, beautiful cinematography and great acting, recommended

  2 out of 2 people found this review helpful

Read all highest rated reviews