Name Discs
Doctor Who - Key Of Marinus
PG Feature

DVD Information

Run time: 2 hours 27 minutes
Rental release: 21 Sep 2009
Main languages: English
Write your own review

Most helpful review Doctor Who - Key Of Marinus

  • 'Classic' is a much abused word

    Rated - 0.0 stars  
    By Spectatorsoflife (6 reviews) from Hove , 10 Dec 2009

    [Highly rated reviewer]

    Everyone is familiar with the budgetary limitations and tight production schedules which reined in the imaginations and compromised the output of all involved in the Dr Who stories of the 60s, 70s and 80s. These constraints are very much in evidence in this outing. What is less frequently acknowledged are the excruciatingly am-dram performances of the cast. Anyone who's seen William Hartnell's acting in 'Brighton Rock' can attest to his on-screen presence. What, then can account for his dismal showing here? Hell, even 'Carry on Sergeant' displayed more conviction than this. A truly wretched experience, which makes even David Tennant's self-satisfied gurning seem bearable by comparison. One to avoid.
    • Was this review helpful to you?
    • (2) Yes |
    •  No (2)

All reviews

(4)
  • give it a chance

    Rated - 3.0 stars  
    By bluetit (4 reviews) from Shildon , 11 May 2011
    this was a good story in the tradition of the who. the effects arnt up to much but as im constantly reminding people at the time there were few computer graphix around to play with all they could muster was a soap box and a sheet of plastic. so i think it was good for the time it was made.
    • Was this review helpful to you?
    • (0) Yes |
    •  No (0)
  • As reliable as ever... but dated

    Rated - 3.0 stars  
    By a customer from Yorkshire , 05 Oct 2010
    Rather like a creaking gate that needs oiling, this story has been lovingly restored by those master cratfsmen at the Restoration team, yet still shows its age. Not surprising, given that this story was broadcast over 35 years ago. Whatever you say about the shallowness (in places) of the new series, and the over-reliance on special effects, I don't think anyone would wish a return to the shoddy camerawork and cut-price scenery that blights these early shows. A special features section has an interview with the designer. Given the amount of money he had to work with, he did wonders! I don't think anyone now would recognise a recorded production where the actors slip and slide over every line and 'um' and 'er' to an uncomfortable conclusion! This would have been cut in the final edit. Yet the story itself stands tall, and could be re-told today without much tweaking.
    • Was this review helpful to you?
    • (0) Yes |
    •  No (0)
  • A great story!

    Rated - 5.0 stars  
    By RickCB (12 reviews) from Pevensey , 13 Mar 2010
    Keys of Marinus is a startlingly original story from the early years of Doctor Who. Travelling from location to location all over the Planet Marinus, the Doctor and his companions and thrust into one danger after another.You can really appreciate the growing bond between the Doctor, his granddaughter and their two initially reluctant travelling companions.
    • Was this review helpful to you?
    • (0) Yes |
    •  No (0)
  • 'Classic' is a much abused word

    Rated - 0.0 stars  
    By Spectatorsoflife (6 reviews) from Hove , 10 Dec 2009

    [Highly rated reviewer]

    Everyone is familiar with the budgetary limitations and tight production schedules which reined in the imaginations and compromised the output of all involved in the Dr Who stories of the 60s, 70s and 80s. These constraints are very much in evidence in this outing. What is less frequently acknowledged are the excruciatingly am-dram performances of the cast. Anyone who's seen William Hartnell's acting in 'Brighton Rock' can attest to his on-screen presence. What, then can account for his dismal showing here? Hell, even 'Carry on Sergeant' displayed more conviction than this. A truly wretched experience, which makes even David Tennant's self-satisfied gurning seem bearable by comparison. One to avoid.
    • Was this review helpful to you?
    • (2) Yes |
    •  No (2)
 

Agree or disagree? Write your own review

Please sign in to LOVEFiLM to write your review

Sign in to LOVEFiLM

Not a member yet?

Sign up to start your 30-day FREE trial