Doctor Who - Planet Of The Dead Details

* * * This review contains spoilers * * *ShowHide

[Highly rated reviewer]

same old rubbish

If you love everything about the show they you have already got the DVD. For others, its the some old RTD writing of giant plot holes (like the stupid bit where the guards are not looking at the gold cup in the museum by having their backs to it then the thief gains access to the cup by lowering herself down from a very well placed hole in the celling (where the top can just be removed). Then the thief leaves a lucky cat which attracts the guard the cup has been stolen. There is plenty more of badly written plot holes. Michelle Ryan is wasted on the role (hopefully she will appear in the new series in 2010) The rest of the cast are poorly written and the effects of the flying bus look terrible

[Highly rated reviewer]

Not among the best

This is perfectly watchable entertainment, but not among the best that Doctor Who has to offer. There's a lack of chemistry between Tennant and Ryan and her inability to stop smiling at absolutely everything becomes rather disconcerting after a while. Still there's an ok premise and the usual watchability. I just hope the one's a little better