Star Wars: Episode 1 - The Phantom Menace Reviews

[Highly rated reviewer]

Hard to see, the dark side is.

The original trilogy introduced special effects never done before on screen; but twenty years later, ILM (Industrial Light & Magic) improved what George Lucas wanted on his masterpiece trilogy. In 1999, now with technology being more advanced, Lucas, has made a film not only of epic storytelling but of visual effects as well.

The film starts out with a Jedi Master Qui-Gon Jinn and a young Obi-Wan Kenobi who disguise themselves as ambassadors for Queen Amidala, which doesn't go well as planned. A droid reveals their identities leaving the Jedi's no choice but to attack. They find out that there's an imminent invasion with the Gungan's, and Jar Jar Binks becomes an aide.

Jar Jar, I'll admit is one of the most annoying characters but thankfully doesn’t appear in any of the other SW films.

The Phantom Menace is a very good start to the prequels but when compared with the rest of the saga, it’s probably the weakest. A fun film nonetheless where there are great fight scenes along the way.

Not A Ghost Of A Chance

After such a long break George Lucas finally got round to making a film to show the beginings of the Star Wars saga. It seems that once and for all he wanted to prove that A New Hope was not just a once off success. Unfortunately, this poorly made prequal utterly fails to convince.

It almost seems as if this movie was made by a different man to the one who made the original Star Wars. In fact this film seems almost to have been made by a complete amateur who was told about the original success of Star Wars and deceided to make a version for children.

The plot is a mess from start to finish ( and I mean the very start, with the scrolling written prologue leading to many puzzled brows on first viewing ). In place of story and drama are special effects and explosions. While this might distract a younger audience most adults are left wondering when the story is going to settle down a bit.

Part of the problem is it all takes itself far too seriously. One of the most likeable characters in the original films was the rogue smuggler Han Solo who was able to provide a more cynical view of the world. In this prequal though there is no one like that and the jedi all talk in plummy English accents so that even their jokes sound serious.

Gone too is the 'lived in world' which Lucas managed so well in Star Wars. Instead of battered old space ships and dusty old clothes everyone dresses immmaculately and the ships are shiney and new. Apparently this was intentional but it does give the film a look reminiscent of some old Flash Gordon episode.

As well as the over the top computer effects George Lucas has tried once again to appeal to the kids with a comedy alien - the universally loathed Jar Jar Binks. Aside from being quite obviously computer generated the voice and manerisms irritate any viewer in a matter of minutes. In addition to this Lucas obviously thought a younger hero might appeal more to children and so we have Anakin Skywalker as a very young child, one who seems to be able to whatever he wants. Allowed to roam around on his own, enter high speed races and fly space craft the boy cannot be more than about eight. He reads his lines and performs as a child put into an adults role and its almost painful to watch.

That said there are a few good points about this movie, ones which I hope might bring more in the sequals. Ewan McGregor is excellent as Obi Wan Kenobi, copying the voice and mannerisms of the original Alec Guiness character perfectly. The Naboo setting is also quite impressive, giving a grandeur and magnificence suitable to an older more romantic age.

Some might say that the audience expected too much of George Lucas for this prequal but I would argue quite the opposite. Fans of Star Wars will be more willing to trust in his work and forgive this film, which without its predecessors would never have stood on its own. Its a very poor piece of cinema and adds nothing to the original movies. The next generation have been poorly treated with this offering which has none of the original magic. We can forgive only so much George....

THIS IS FOR A NEW GENERATION!!!

This movie takes a lot of stick, mostly from people who have seen at least twice in the cinema and now own it on DVD!! This movie isnt for people who have seen the original trilogy; its for the new batch; and in my opinion it is a great stand alone kids movie that cleverly introduces them to a series of complicated characters, political ideas and most importantly good and evil. By the time they see attack of the clones and revenge of the sith they will be ready to embrace the original trilogy; perhaps even more so than old brigade! MAY THE FORCE BE WITH THEM!

Very pretty, but pretty vacant too

Some of the best 'eye candy' ever in one of the worst insults to the intelligence!

The good points: Absolutely stunning visually. The capital of the planet at the heart of the story is incredibly beautifully realised. The race is also very well done.

The bad points: For everyone over the age of two, it's completely obvious what will happen. Just who is the leader of the evil forces, for example? Could it, just possibly, be... Of course it is. There are also some huge gaping plot holes, and someone who should have been given several extra holes in his head: JaJa Blinks.

(Ewan deserved an Academy Award for saying "It's good to see you" to JarJar in the sequel...)

It's worth watching, but switch off your brain first and just revel in the visuals.

[Highly rated reviewer]

INSULT to the original films

Who was this made for ?

Visually appealing, but totally reliant on computer effects, nothing new or interesting really.

What makes the film terrible, is the utterly jibberish baby nonsense dialogue, that, well, may appeal to 6 month old babies, who find cartoons too intellectual.

Really, it is totally dire, and the cast is so badly miscast , it's a joke, cringe is the understatement of the year here.

I stopped watching half way through, I just couldn't take any more of the stupid animated creatures, and the even worse brainless dialogue.

NO idea why Lucas produced such rubbish, this man was a creative genius, but how on Earth did he allow this fiasco to happen ?

This film is Star Wars only in name, it has nothing to do with the original films, and is frankly appalling.

A total embarrasment.

Very disappointing

It's not often that I say something is a real Bernard Matthews job and TPM isn't quite that bad. Episode Two deserves that accolade, but as a supposed prequel to the Star Wars classics, this doesn't do much to build up any excitement.

Liam Neeson is all grace and dignity, Ewan McGregor shows he can do a passable Alec Guinness impression and the evil looking baddie - Darth Maul - is criminally underused.

Jedi knights look cool when they're running around making objects fly all over the place but there's not too much of the knight aspect, men of honour fighting to keep the peace.

The score is the usual John Williams high standard and you can almost figure out what's going to happen in the plot just by listening to the score alone.

I left the cinema feeling this was a missed opportunity and hoping for something better in episode two. A few years on and I still feel the same way.

Episodes 4, 5 and 6 are still well ahead of episodes 1 and 2.

Abysmal

In an alternate universe, where episodes IV-VI where never released, Lucas could never have found a publisher for this garbage, and a sequal would never be released, I've seen 'Made for TV' movies that have better acting, story and characters.

The Beginning of a Saga

The film is beautiful to look at but due to most of the film being taken up by introduction of characters, sometimes the film does drag in places. The CGI used tends to overtake the film from the story and some of the characters are quite inaudible. Overall, the film is a good beginning and makes you eager to see how the film will come together with the proposed sequels. Not the best in the series but important for the story.

Could so easily have been so much better

In The original Star Wars film, we were given a description of civilised times of the old republic, where great knights were guardians of the peace.

And then, nearly 30 years later we finally got to see these ancient, mythical times... and they had poo jokes, unconvincing characters, appalling dialogue and a storyline that just trips over itself in idiotic confusion.

Too convoluted and badly-paced for kids to love, and too reliant on appallingly mishandled, childish humour for adults to get into, this film manages to miss both its potential targets.

The effects are fantastic, although I can't help but feel an over-reliance on CGI and blue screens was partly responsible for some very poor acting.

The shame about Episode I is that it could so easily have been great, had the basic but fudamental elements of story and scrpit been thought out more. And lets face it, George Lucas had years to think about it!

Episodes II and III were progressively better, but this one opened plot holes which were never to be closed, and provided none of the simple magic expected of Star Wars .

Episode I lacks cohesion and forethought in the most basic of areas, and is the key example of where the prequel trilogy went wrong.

Kids Loved It

I myself am not a great fan of Star Wars (never actually watched one) but my kids absolutely love it. Totally mesmorised by it they wouldnt move away from the tv. The were gutted that I have had to send it back so I have had to promise to buy it for them. Never mind! They love It