loading loading...

The Wind Will Carry Us Reviews

1999 Certificate U
  • 60
  • from 228 members

A few people arrive from Tehran for a short stay at Siah Dareh, a village in Iranian Kurdistan. The locals do not know why they are there. The strangers wander around the former cemetery and let the villagers think that they are looking for treasure. They end up leaving without really giving the impression that they have found .. Read more

Starring Noghre Asadi, Bahman Ghobadi
Director Abbas Kiarostami
Genres Drama, World Cinema

Buy From: £11.93

loading loading...

  • Critics' reviews (2) of The Wind Will Carry Us

    View all
  • 2 stars out of 4

    This is film making refined to a point where only metaphors remain, which can be read in the landscape, particularly the road to the cemetery along which the leader of the mysterious visitors races so that he can use his mobile phone: the message is that

    • Halliwell's Film Guide
  • Another subtle, deceptively simple and richly rewarding work of genius from Kiarostami, this Venice prizewinner opens... read more on Time Out

    • Time Out
  • Most helpful members' reviews (3) of The Wind Will Carry Us

    View all
  • 17 out of 19 people found this review helpful

    Rated - 0.0 stars

    Pointless + very boring.

    I am very keen on foreign arthouse films. But this was extremely boring. The whole film seemed to be based around a man trying to get reception for his mobile ... more

      • A customer from East Sussex
  • 6 out of 6 people found this review helpful

    Rated - 0.0 stars

    Treason

    What hacked me off as an Iranian person is that Mr Abbas Kiarostami (director) has a knack for finding some remote, under privileged, old villages and he does ... more

      • SonikBoy from Newcastle upon Tyne
  • Rated - 4.0 stars [Highly rated reviewer]

    Waiting for Mrs Godarzi

    This rather beautiful film is confident enough not to feel it necessary to labour the plot. However, in essence, a group of possibly journalists have travelled ... more

      • Leni from London
  • Most recent members' reviews (2) of The Wind Will Carry Us

    View all
  • 17 out of 19 people found this review helpful

    Rated - 0.0 stars

    Pointless + very boring.

    I am very keen on foreign arthouse films. But this was extremely boring. The whole film seemed to be based around a man trying to get reception for his mobile ... more

      • A customer from East Sussex
  • Rated - 0.0 stars

    the wind will carry us

    Not sure how this film ever got any stars, I agree with the other two reviewers. It may have lost something in translation, but never did quite work out what ... more

      • A customer from Canterbury
  • 17 out of 19 people found this review helpful

    Rated - 0.0 stars

    Pointless + very boring.

    I am very keen on foreign arthouse films. But this was extremely boring. The whole film seemed to be based around a man trying to get reception for his mobile ... more

      • A customer from East Sussex
  • 6 out of 6 people found this review helpful

    Rated - 0.0 stars

    Treason

    What hacked me off as an Iranian person is that Mr Abbas Kiarostami (director) has a knack for finding some remote, under privileged, old villages and he does ... more

      • SonikBoy from Newcastle upon Tyne
  • Rated - 4.0 stars [Highly rated reviewer]

    Waiting for Mrs Godarzi

    This rather beautiful film is confident enough not to feel it necessary to labour the plot. However, in essence, a group of possibly journalists have travelled ... more

      • Leni from London
  • Rated - 3.0 stars

    ?????????????

    What was all this film about. Reminded me a bit of 'Groundhog Day' at some points! Strange film but watched it until the end anyway.

      • A customer from Arbroath
  • Rated - 0.0 stars

    the wind will carry us

    Not sure how this film ever got any stars, I agree with the other two reviewers. It may have lost something in translation, but never did quite work out what ... more

      • A customer from Canterbury
  • Critics' reviews (2)

  • 2 stars out of 4

    This is film making refined to a point where only metaphors remain, which can be read in the landscape, particularly the road to the cemetery along which the leader of the mysterious visitors races so that he can use his mobile phone: the message is that

    • Halliwell's Film Guide
  • Another subtle, deceptively simple and richly rewarding work of genius from Kiarostami, this Venice prizewinner opens... read more on Time Out

    • Time Out
Good review materials:
  • Highlights of the DVD's content and context
  • What you liked and disliked and why
  • How the DVD compares to other similar titles
Poor review materials:
  • Tiny reviews - give us at least a full sentence
  • Inappropriate or adult-only content, such as obscene, libellous or rude
  • Promotional content such as alternative ordering/pricing information
  • Reviews mentioning LOVEFiLM by name
Your name:
Your location:
Nickname:
Review title:
  • 60

Contains spoiler?

Please note that if you write a spoiler (what's this?) without warning other members, LOVEFiLM reserves its rights to blacklist you and discard any further submissions you make to www.lovefilm.com.

Your submission must be your own original work and will normally be posted on this web site within 1 business day. Please do not include HTML tags; for a new paragraph, insert a blank line.

Buy from the LOVEFiLM shop


    • The Wind Will Carry Us
    • DVD: £11.93
      Free Delivery
    • RRP £15.99 (you save: 25%)
    • A few people arrive from Tehran for a short stay at Siah Dareh, a village in Iranian Kurdistan. The locals do not know why they are there. The strangers wander around the former cemetery and let the ...

Rating breakdown

228 Member ratings
  • 100
24
  • 90
17
  • 80
40
  • 70
39
  • 60
40
  • 50
21
  • 40
11
  • 30
11
  • 20
14
  • 10
11

Related News & Features

Related user collection

Celebrity collection