Skip over navigation

Help

Carandiru on DVD (2003)

Carandiru cover art
Average rating: 71%
1112513172059
3.0
from 491 members
 
Starring: Luis Carlos Vasconcelos, Milhem Cortaz, Milton Goncalves, Ivan De Almeida, Ailton Graca
Director: Hector Babenco
Studio: COLUMBIA TRI-STAR HOME VIDEO
Run time: 149 mins
Certificate: 15
User collections: Mindblowing Films, something diferent, An Anthropologist's Favourites, Subtitled gems, Brazilian Greats, Brazilian Best
Genres: Drama
Languages: Portuguese
Dubbed: Spanish
Hearing-impaired: English
Subtitles: Arabic, Czech, Danish, Dutch, English, Finnish, Greek, Hebrew, Hindi, Hungarian, Icelandic, Norwegian, Polish, Portuguese, Spanish, Swedish, Turkish
Released: 23/07/2004

Brief synopsis of Carandiru

Acclaimed Argentinean director Hector Babenco (KISS OF THE SPIDER WOMAN, PIXOTE), blends pathos and black comedy in this adaptation of the autobiographical book CARANDIRU STATION by Dr. Drauzio Varella, who worked inside Sao Paulo's now-defunct Carandiru Prison. In 1992, overcrowded Carandiru gained international infamy when military police troops, called to quell a riot, killed 111 inmates. The Carandiru population contained murderers, drug dealers, and all manner of petty criminals--all guilty--but also driven to crime by Brazilian poverty. Dr. Varella, a renowned oncologist, arrived at Carandiru to help with AIDS prevention, but stayed and began to treat the inmates for everything from rat bites to rape, and in the process shared their life stories.
Director Babenco articulates the horror suffered by these men by recounting the darkly humorous stories of their families and personal lives, and then uses that empathy to show the terror of the police attack. After detailing the state-sponsored massacre, the film ends with the patriotic song "Aquarela do Brasil," providing one last emotional jab. Like his exploration of poverty and crime in previous films such as PIXOTE, Babenco creates a frenzied and emotionally weighted story, filmed on location in Carandiru Prison just before it closed. The film signifies the global need to improve social conditions and places a human face on the anonymous prison system.

Related

Critics Reviews

Rating of 4 stars out of 5 Radio Times

Hector Babenco's harrowing true story of conditions inside Carandiru, the biggest prison in South America, leaves you scorched and exhausted. The jail's brutality and squalor is introduced through the eyes of a new doctor (Luiz Carlos Vasconcelos), brought in to help control an escalating Aids epidemic. Despite the depravity, he finds solidarity and a lust for life among the inmates, who divulge their stories to him in a series of episodes that take in a gay wedding, a balloon-maker and a hitman's religious conversion. Babenco brought a new touch to prison drama in 1985 with Kiss of the Spider Woman, but that was a chamberwork compared with the sprawl of Carandiru, which uses at least a thousand extras in its second-half riot scenes. Babenco's control over everything might not be altogether firm, but his device of letting inhabitants explain themselves to camera is highly effective, and he ably keeps us hearing the rumble of discontent that will later erupt into nightmare rebellion.

Time Out

Based on the memoirs of a doctor, Drauzio Varella, who administered at São Paulo's most notorious prison, Babenco's... Read more on www.timeout.com

Rating of 1 
	  stars out of 4 Halliwell's Film Guide

Episodic drama, based on fact, that compassionately explores individual lives reduced to a horrific existence.

See all 3 Critics Reviews »

Members Reviews

Reviews Voted Most Helpful

Rated - 5 starsA film of the highest quality!!!!

Gonzo Soul from The Thoroughfare, Woodbridge , 31/08/2004

Wow!!! This is probably the best film I've seen in a long time!!!

This film truely has it all... great photography, brilliant acting, an involving story which turns gripping towards the final act. I really liked the way small stories about how people got into Carandiru branched off the main story of the build up to the riot.

A definate future classic! Long live Brazillian cinema!!

  34 out of 36 people found this review helpful
Report offending content.

Read all reviews

Rated - 4 starsGripping angry cinema

Melon from East Sussex , 03/09/2004

This has been compared to 'City of God' because they're both violent, Brazilian and feature large casts and a multitude of plotlines. The comparison is a little unfair to both sides, as 'Carandiru' lacks 'City's' wildly kinetic energy and dazzle.

This is after all a film set within the walls of a very,very grim prison (albeit regularly leaving those walls as it delves into the stories of how the inmates ended up there much like TV series 'Oz' did, and there are a lot of similarities here). It's a far more contemplative and theatrical work, not at all flashy, as Babenco is an old pro providing solid camera shots, all round perfect performances, and a documentary authenticity. He brings out the warmth as well as the horror of life in the overcrowded hellhole.

The climatic massacre is genuinely scary and shocking. This is a very, very bleak film, but for those with the guts pays dividends.

  12 out of 13 people found this review helpful
Report offending content.

Read all reviews

Rated - 5 starsBrilliant character film

dustybinlyd from Norfolk , 26/01/2005

Fantastic film, well shot and good character introduction. One of those films where you forget you're watching subtitles after the first 5mins. A most excellently portrayed story of life inside one of Brazils most notorious prison, made all the more interesting because its a true story and the extra footage even includes silent film from the 1920s when the prison was a model prison and newly built.

Fascinating and worth recommending to everyone.

  8 out of 9 people found this review helpful
Report offending content.

Read all reviews

Most Recent Reviews

Rated - 3 starsWORTH A LOOK

THEMAINMAN from Stevenston [Highly rated reviewer] , 13/12/2007

THIS IS ABOUT THE PRISON WHICH INSPIRED THE ONE IN PRISON BREAK SERIES 3,ONCE YOU WATCH IT YOU WILL UNDERSTAND,IT6S A GOOD FILM,NOT AS VIOLENT AS I EXPECTED BUT WORTH A LOOK ANY WAY.DONT LET THE SUBTITLES PUT YOU OFF!

  1 out of 1 person found this review helpful
Report offending content.

Read all highest rated reviews