Skip over navigation

Help

The Singing Detective on DVD (2003)

The Singing Detective cover art
Play The Singing Detective trailer
Average rating: 48%
31151210207512
2.0
from 191 members
 
Starring: Robert Downey Jr, Robin Wright Penn, Mel Gibson, Katie Holmes, Jeremy Northam, Adrien Brody
Director: Keith Gordon
Studio: MGM ENTERTAINMENT
Run time: 109 mins
Certificate: 15
Genres: Drama, Music/Musical, Romance
Languages: English
Released: 19/07/2004

Brief synopsis of The Singing Detective

Director Keith Gordon (MOTHER NIGHT, WAKING THE DEAD) makes another brave adaptation with THE SINGING DETECTIVE. Based on Dennis Potter's stunningly brilliant 1986 mini-series of the same name, Gordon's version finds the film's troubled hero transplanted to 1950s America, not post-WWII London. Dan Dark (Robert Downey Jr.) is a pulp novelist in the thralls of a crippling skin disease that has rendered him delusional and immobile. Bitter, angry, and at the end of his tether, Dan manages to offend everyone he encounters. As he lies in bed, scenes from his novel swim into his mind, blurring with experiences from his own childhood. In the present, he remains paranoid that his ex-wife Nicola (Robin Wright Penn) is out to steal a script he wrote. Adding to his disgust are forced visits with an uptight psychotherapist, Dr. Gibbon (Mel Gibson), who is determined to make a breakthrough with his hateful patient. Along the way, Dan envisions several musical sequences, which appear out of nowhere and add glorious confusion to his fevered state. Gordon, working from a script that Potter himself wrote before his death, delivers an imaginary, vibrant film that is aided greatly by Robert Downey Jr.'s ferocious performance.

Related

Critics Reviews

Halliwell's Film Guide

Much less successful than the original BBC TV series, this has lost the dark urgency of the original, and its much shorter running time and transfer to an American setting also diminish it.

Members Reviews

Reviews Voted Most Helpful

Rated - 1 starsOh Dear

A customer from Suffolk England , 05/07/2004

Not a patch on the tv series which just goes to show that star names doesnt equal star performances.Robert Downey isnt at all convincing in the lead role which overstretches his meagre acting talents.Where is Micheal Gambon when you need him.

  8 out of 13 people found this review helpful
Report offending content.

Read all reviews

Rated - 5 starsA worthwile effort from Mel Gibson

JG Weston from Chelmsford Essex , 12/01/2005

This is not as good as the TV series, of course, that was twice the length and allowed for more twists and turns in the plot. However for those who did not get the full value from the TV series (there is a lot in it) this makes a good introduction. It is simpler but still contains the essence, after all Dennis Potter did write the screen play (as in the plot). Mel Gibson has done us all a service in putting this on film, even though most of the reviewers in here don't think so, I wonder if they fully understood the TV version either.

If you are in doubt about the value of this film then watch Mel Gibsons interview in the extras.

JG

  7 out of 11 people found this review helpful
Report offending content.

Read all reviews

Rated - 2 starsAm I right or am I right?

Leon Collins from London , 31/03/2005

Watching the film version of The Singing Detective I was determined to judge it on its own terms and not make comparisons with Dennis Potter's TV masterpiece. Unfortunately Robert Downey Jr fails to convince that he is in great physical and mental pain as a result of the psorasis that covers his body or hint at the psychologically damaged personality beneath. The use of 50s music in Dan Dark's fantasy flashbacks dosn't work with the 40s film noir/pulp fiction settings, perhaps Sinatra would have been a better choice that Johnny Ray and Gene Vincent. Mel Gibson's turn as a nerdy psychiatrist who unlocks Dark's past is an highlight in an otherwise disappointing film.Rent the 3-disk DVD of the original series instead. Am I right or am I right?

  5 out of 6 people found this review helpful
Report offending content.

Read all reviews

Rated - 4 starsWeird!

DrAndyP from West Sussex , 16/08/2004

I think I enjoyed this film but my head is still spinning so bear with me!

Only Dennis Potter could write something so dark, comic and touching at the same time.

Robert Downey Jnr plays Dan Dark, an author languishing in a hospital bed with disfiguring and agonizing psoriatic arthritis. To avoid the pain (and his troubled past) he escapes into a fantasy world where he is a 50’s detective complete with fedora, dangling cigarette and all the ‘dames’ you can shake a stick at. Trouble starts when the lines between fantasy and reality become blurred. He attempts to find a handle on reality with the help of a psychiatrist, Dr Gibbon, brilliantly (and unrecognisable) played by Mel Gibson.

This film is well worth watching but don’t expect an easy ride, it’s not a Friday night popcorn film which, to be honest, makes a refreshing change.

  4 out of 5 people found this review helpful
Report offending content.

Read all reviews

Most Recent Reviews

Rated - 1 starsI hired the wrong film

MrSicky from Berkshire , 04/02/2005

Sat down to watch this saw Robert Downey Junior with scabs all over his face in the first five minutes and decided, no this film isn't for me.

  2 out of 2 people found this review helpful
Report offending content.

Read all highest rated reviews

Rated - 4 starsPotter fans need only apply

Carpocrates from surrey , 17/08/2004

The question was would they be able to make an 8 hour mini series into a 2 hour movie?

Yes is the answer, this is a really good adaptation, with marvellous performances, (except Adrien Brody, I think he must have just got lucky with the Oscar!). Potter wrote the screenplay himself.

If you don’t like whacky films where people burst into song for no apparent reason this is not for you! However if you are a fan of Potters or Downey Jnr this is a must with an outstanding sound track a really enjoyable movie.

  2 out of 2 people found this review helpful
Report offending content.

Read all highest rated reviews