Lovers Of The Arctic Circle on DVD (1998)

More inspired than Sex and Lucia

RichD from W Sussex , 19/01/2004

I can recommend this film. The early scenes of how the lovers meet as eight years olds are most beautifully shot and, I found, stunning in the clarity with which they present the complex personalities of the young kids. No patronising view of what makes a child tick from Julio Medem - it’s full on. Appreciate the seemingly effortless way he presents the physiological dependencies of the young pair.

Beautiful but sometimes painful childhood leads into a sensual but even more painful adolescence. The lovers show decisiveness to bring their destinies together but the destructive forces of broken family betrayal and death combine to shake it all apart before the transition to adulthood.

Thus we are left with the crux of the matter, will they find the chance on the winds of fate to be together - for ever?

It’s not without sentimentality, but I forgive Medem that. Who knows how close we have been to fulfilling the biggest desires of our lives, but just failed to seize the chance that we sensed was close but invisible? Medem is toying with the "what if?" as if to say who really knows? You never really know. Equally, the overly symmetrical coincidences in the family stories that lead the lovers together did not trouble me. It served just to emphasise that sometimes we live in other dimensions that to us are more important than reality. This is the dimension that Julio Medem accesses with ease.

Read all reviews

Left me cold

Bill Hardwick from Cheshire , 20/09/2005

I was totally unable to relate to this film at any level. Not helped by often illegible subtitles, it seemed a vacuous exercise. It is the only film I've rented so far that I failed to watch to the end - plain bored.

Read all reviews

Quirky

Andrew from Scotland , 07/05/2004

A little too quriky for it's own good, and a lack of chemistry from the leads leaves this a little disappointing. It can be seen what the film was trying to achieve - it just fell short.

Read all reviews

The intention is good but...

DMuller from Roehampton , 09/05/2005

This film is about two lovers who know each other from childhood and their fight against destiny to be together. The approach is somewhat original in that the story is told from the point of view of the boy and the girl alternately. The rhythm is slow but not oppressively slow and the overall tone is slightly magical. Not a bad film but it?s spoiled by a contrived script which sometimes makes the two main characters choose the options directly opposed to their feelings, just for the sake of enhancing the fatalistic quality of the story.

See ?The Red Squirrel?, by the same director. The script is more fluid (though not more natural), the performances are better and the film is more enigmatic and interesting.

By the way, some people believe that this film is set in the Spanish speaking community in Finland. Actually, most of the action happens in Spain and only a few scenes are set in Finland. I suppose that the confusion arises from a scene where the two lovers are riding a sledge in the snow. That scene happens in Spain, country where it snows every winter.

Read all reviews

More inspired than Sex and Lucia

RichD from W Sussex , 19/01/2004

I can recommend this film. The early scenes of how the lovers meet as eight years olds are most beautifully shot and, I found, stunning in the clarity with which they present the complex personalities of the young kids. No patronising view of what makes a child tick from Julio Medem - it’s full on. Appreciate the seemingly effortless way he presents the physiological dependencies of the young pair.

Beautiful but sometimes painful childhood leads into a sensual but even more painful adolescence. The lovers show decisiveness to bring their destinies together but the destructive forces of broken family betrayal and death combine to shake it all apart before the transition to adulthood.

Thus we are left with the crux of the matter, will they find the chance on the winds of fate to be together - for ever?

It’s not without sentimentality, but I forgive Medem that. Who knows how close we have been to fulfilling the biggest desires of our lives, but just failed to seize the chance that we sensed was close but invisible? Medem is toying with the "what if?" as if to say who really knows? You never really know. Equally, the overly symmetrical coincidences in the family stories that lead the lovers together did not trouble me. It served just to emphasise that sometimes we live in other dimensions that to us are more important than reality. This is the dimension that Julio Medem accesses with ease.

Read all highest rated reviews

A typically fractured contrivance from Sr Medem

Savage from London, England [Highly rated reviewer] , 01/05/2007

Julio Medem, who wrote and directed this film, studied psychiatry at medical school before dropping out to become a film critic and, eventually, a director. All of his films bear the hallmark of his education, but none of them are quite as profound as he seems to like to think.

Here he takes a boy and a girl, throws them randomly together, has them fall in love, and then shatters their relationship (and their lives, and the lives of their immediate families - except those who get as far away as possible, to Australia) before teasing his audience that there might still be a chance for a reconciliation. The key scene appears to be the one in the gift shop, played out in front of a baffled sales assistant, unsure whether she's watching young love or your actual incest. Once the balance, particularly in Otto's mind, is broken by his mother's sudden death, nothing can be the same again: flirting with fate brings its own revenge.

The film is either compelling and charming in its reflections on the whimsicality of fate and love, or thoroughly irritating in its switchback ride. I lean towards the former, but I'm not entirely convinced.

Read all highest rated reviews