Big Red One, The - The Reconstruction on DVD (1980)

Northernsky from Halifax [Highly rated reviewer] , 25/07/2005

This is the restored version of Director Sam Fullers WW2 epic, the original was deemed too violent by the studio (Imagine, a violent war film…..tsskk) and cut to ribbons so it made no narrative sense. Original material has been added by a restoration team and now this is a film with the resolute stamp of empirical authority. Fuller fought in WW2, taking part in the Omaha beach landings and his minds eye view of proceedings lends this film a veracity few can match.

The main characters are all part of the 1st Infantry, the “Big Red One” of the films title, named after their insignia,. Ex Marine Lee Marvin in his last great role plays the gruff Sergeant along with Privates Griff, Zab Vinci and Johnson. Griff is played by Mark Hamill at the peak of his “Star Wars” fame. We follow them from North Africa to Sicily onto Omaha Beach and through Europe until they liberate a Concentration Camp in Czechoslovakia. The film is a series of intense battle sequences, interspersed by periods of quiet reflection, jokey banter and the cold dread of death.

There is grim humour in the script, but also poetry and understated emotion. Modern films about war are now made by people referencing other war movies and while The Big Red One doesn’t have anything as viscerally shocking as the opening sequence of “Saving Private Ryan”, unlike that jingoistic preposterous movie it rings true with an almost documentary realism.

  8 out of 10 people found this review helpful

Read all reviews

Nimrod from London , 03/05/2005

Based on Fuller's own wartime experiences, this tells the picaresque story of a sergeant and four of his men as they travel through the various theatres of WW2. The tone is one of reportage and although sequences are handled with flair, there is deliberately no attempt to make a definitive statement about war.

This appears to be the "reconstructed" version (the studio made Fuller cut entire battles out of the 1980 release).

Although Fuller notably denounced "Full Metal Jacket" as "a recruiting poster", this film is probably nearer in tone to that than to any other war movie. Although it has surreal moments, it never veers off into "Apocalypse Now" territory and in many ways harks back to earlier WW2 films, albeit with far more grit.

It's also a lot more more realistic about what soldiers are like than for example Spielberg.

Bleak and almost nihilistic, this shows war as utter madness which you survive as best you can through luck and cunning. Surely a lesson many of us need to relearn in 2005.

  5 out of 6 people found this review helpful

Read all reviews

A customer from Wales , 01/05/2005

This is one of the most poignant war fils ever made. Indeed it helped inspire the beach battle sequence in Saving Private Ryan. Lee Marvin is perfectly cast as the Sergeant, indeed he was able to draw on his experience as an ex-marine. Ultimatley the film drives home the futility of war.

  4 out of 5 people found this review helpful

Read all reviews

A customer from London , 27/05/2005

For it's time, this was an excellent war film, especially now, with all scenes restored. However, with all of the modern, big budget films and series such as Privae Ryan and Band of Brothers we have grown to expect more: acting, drama, as well as technical effects.

Still, well worth the viewing.

One funny note: not only did Lee Marvin not get any older between WWI and WWII, but after 20+ years in the army, he still is only an E5 Sargent!

  2 out of 2 people found this review helpful

Read all reviews