John Q. on DVD (2002)

Powerful enough to hide its weaknesses

Gordon Walker from Northern Ireland , 08/04/2004

An involving, beautifully acted, sometime manipulative issue film, 'John Q' is the story of a factory worker (Washington as John Archibald) whose son is suddenly struck down with heart disease. Given a choice between making little Mike comfortable until he dies and the risk of a heart transplant the distraught parents opt for the transplant confident that their medical insurance will pay for everything. However, John discovers to his horror that because recent downturns have left him working 20 hours a week his employer's policy classifies him as part time and only provides $20,000 dollars of cover. This won't even pay the $75,000 deposit required for surgery. Provoked by his inability to provide for his family or pay for his son's surgery John is driven to desperate measures when he takes the emergency room hostage and demands that his son be put on the transplant list.

Structurally this is an issue-of-the-week TV movie, what transforms it are the sterling performances of a very strong cast. Denzel Washington's portrayal of the tormented father is pitch perfect and Kimberly Elise, as his wife, maintains a nice balance, simultaneously demanding the impossible of her beleagered husband while still showing her love for him thus retaining our sympathy. Robert Duvall brings suitable gravitas to a light and somewhat underwritten part and James Wood manages to make something of his awkwardly written role as the heart surgeon. Anne Heche's character is the weakest link although this again can be ascribed in large measure to a script that makes her just a little too callous to be realistic.

Weak writing in the supporting characters notwithstanding the film works very well overall, hanging primarily on Washington's work which provides the believable dynamic behind the whole plot. The minor roles of the hostages, while somewhat cliched are carried off well and the pacing is very good.

Apart from an ending which was not quite what it could have been the film is very satisfying.

Read all reviews

Excellent Film

Janine from Yorkshire , 27/07/2004

This is an excellent film and keeps you watching all the way through and is about a father, who's son is denied a operation because they are not covered on his insurance, so he takes matters into is own hands and anyone in is position would do the same

Read all reviews

Strangely lacking in tension

Darth Egregious from London , 04/12/2005

I suppose its because you just have a feeling about this film that no-one is going to die. Hence, everything is just a case of going through the motions. Plus what really annoyed me was the fact that this whole plot comes about because Americans are not prepared to pay higher taxes for a basic level of healthcare on a par with the NHS - but this basic truth is given one line at the end of the film! Yet we get a whole five minute segment where doctors and hospitals are portrated as nothing but money grubbing monsters. Is this film slightly biased for its audience, perhaps?

Read all reviews

JOHN Q

MIKEY1 from Surrey , 20/10/2003

THIS IS ONE OF THOSE MOVIES THAT SHOWS WHAT A FATHER IS PREPARED TO DO FOR HIS FAMILY - HE WILL GO TO ANY LENGHTS. AN EXCELLENT PERFORMANCE BY DENZEL. THIS IS ONE FOR THE WHOLE FAMILY.

Read all reviews

Powerful enough to hide its weaknesses

Gordon Walker from Northern Ireland , 08/04/2004

An involving, beautifully acted, sometime manipulative issue film, 'John Q' is the story of a factory worker (Washington as John Archibald) whose son is suddenly struck down with heart disease. Given a choice between making little Mike comfortable until he dies and the risk of a heart transplant the distraught parents opt for the transplant confident that their medical insurance will pay for everything. However, John discovers to his horror that because recent downturns have left him working 20 hours a week his employer's policy classifies him as part time and only provides $20,000 dollars of cover. This won't even pay the $75,000 deposit required for surgery. Provoked by his inability to provide for his family or pay for his son's surgery John is driven to desperate measures when he takes the emergency room hostage and demands that his son be put on the transplant list.

Structurally this is an issue-of-the-week TV movie, what transforms it are the sterling performances of a very strong cast. Denzel Washington's portrayal of the tormented father is pitch perfect and Kimberly Elise, as his wife, maintains a nice balance, simultaneously demanding the impossible of her beleagered husband while still showing her love for him thus retaining our sympathy. Robert Duvall brings suitable gravitas to a light and somewhat underwritten part and James Wood manages to make something of his awkwardly written role as the heart surgeon. Anne Heche's character is the weakest link although this again can be ascribed in large measure to a script that makes her just a little too callous to be realistic.

Weak writing in the supporting characters notwithstanding the film works very well overall, hanging primarily on Washington's work which provides the believable dynamic behind the whole plot. The minor roles of the hostages, while somewhat cliched are carried off well and the pacing is very good.

Apart from an ending which was not quite what it could have been the film is very satisfying.

Read all highest rated reviews

Excellent Film

Janine from Yorkshire , 27/07/2004

This is an excellent film and keeps you watching all the way through and is about a father, who's son is denied a operation because they are not covered on his insurance, so he takes matters into is own hands and anyone in is position would do the same

Read all highest rated reviews